Showing posts with label Monique Meloche. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Monique Meloche. Show all posts

Thursday, February 23, 2012

Editorial: Todd Chilton vis-a-vis Scott Stack

Chicago painters Todd Chilton and Scott Stack seem good to bring together in comparison. Independent of one another, both artists have recently produced abstract works in which successive, regular, linear elements dominate the canvas. Having written that, between Chilton and Stack there is too a telling difference in manipulation of line and color--a difference indicative of opposing strategies for pattern formation and the perception thereof. Coincidentally, in the not-too-distant past, the pair opened shows only two weeks and three miles apart.

Todd Chilton @ Rhona Hoffman
Above: Todd Chilton @ Rhona Hoffman, October 28 - December 3, 2011, edge detail

Scott Stack Preview Monique Meloche
Above: Scott Stack @ Monique Meloche, October 15 – November 12, 2011, edge detail

In a previous article, on October 13, 2011, two days in advance of his exhibition at Monique Meloche Gallery, Scott Stack was recorded as follows: "'I'm not interested in pure green, or pure red, or anything straight out of the tube,' he said, 'That's not color.'"[1]

Whether his (Stack's) words were driven by prescience or exasperation, that formal antithesis which he conjured in speech was seen realized by Todd Chilton at Rhona Hoffman Gallery, on October 28, 2011.

Todd Chilton @ Rhona Hoffman
Above: Todd Chilton @ Rhona Hoffman, October 28 - December 3, 2011, edge detail

In Chilton's presentation at Hoffman, more-or-less solid colors in alternation were used to build linear elements within paintings. Band-of-paint to band-of-paint, transitions were seen to be relatively abrupt and high in contrast; internal borders were well-defined, even if painterly. The periodic reversal of value and/or hue within said bands was, in aggregate, sometimes productive of a weak "gestalt effect," according to which geometric figures were able to be recognized.[2]

Todd Chilton @ Rhona Hoffman
Above: Todd Chilton @ Rhona Hoffman, October 28 - December 3, 2011

In this regard, Chilton wholly depended upon his viewer's ability to psychologically complete his half-painted patterns: secondary shapes, however simple, e.g., diamond, needed to be known (knowable) in whole aforehand.

Conversely, in his most recent show at Meloche, Stack displayed a commitment to blending not only in his palette but also in the paint having been applied to the canvas. Movement from color-to-color and line-to-line within Stack's new paintings was usually characterized by a compact but gradual gradient progression; it was refined. Where Chilton's (impasto) surfaces were thick and tempestuous, Stack's surfaces were remarkably shallow and placid in spite of hours of brushwork.

It was in his composition that Stack roiled enigmatically, as the organization of his lines appeared stochastic, whether such activity was said to have some original correspondence to objective reality. Here, Stack was open as Rorschach to readings as yet unknown to himself or his audience.[3]

Above: Scott Stack, "Return of the Leopard Woman," 2009, oil on canvas, 89 x 74 inches, original image from Monique Meloche Gallery.

Stack is, roughly, twice Chilton's age; Stack must have held a brush for more than twice as many years as Chilton. And it's tempting to attribute at least some difference in their current work to said temporal disparity: What in youth seems clear, a matter of earnest to be vigorously pursued, frequently becomes a more complicated and ambiguous affair as the years pass. Why Chilton and Stack should have drawn relatively near one another, however briefly, now, is a yet more difficult thing to guess.

Historically, Scott Stack had seemed to be committed to the representation of abstractions--and not to representation or abstraction per se.[4] Painting the imagery reproduced by electronic devices, e.g., night vision equipment or television, Stack had spent years painting scenes already multiple generations distant from reality.[5][6] And it had been fairly easy to nestle him (Stack) in the near precedents set by Chicago Imagists: linking his apartment exteriors to Roger Brown, and his figure work to Ed Paschke.

Above: Scott Stack, "7:30pm Apartment," oil on canvas, 78 x 66 inches, original image from Monique Meloche Gallery.

Above: Scott Stack, "Queen," 2009, oil on canvas, 100 x 66 inches, original image from Monique Meloche Gallery.

Stack was a sort of surrealist with a conceptual bent, a foot in each local camp. But, Stack's more recent work recalls another continent almost one hundred years ago, in which time and place Cubism and Futurism were incubated. Maybe, Stack recalls Fernand Leger particularly.[7]

Above: Scott Stack, "Untitled," 2011, oil on canvas, 68 x 78 inches, original image from Monique Meloche Gallery.

Locally, Todd Chilton has been repeatedly associated with the purely formal issues of his craft.[8] And Chilton does indeed seem to be a painter of paintings: any reference external to the activity of himself, his viewer, and art history, appears limited if at all extant in his work. To the extent that Chilton is involved in a re-imagining of Op and Hard-Edge painting he too, like Stack, relies heavily upon abstractions which already exist somewhere in visual culture.

Todd Chilton @ Rhona Hoffman
Above: Todd Chilton @ Rhona Hoffman, October 28 - December 3, 2011, installation view

Todd Chilton @ Rhona Hoffman
Above: Todd Chilton @ Rhona Hoffman, October 28 - December 3, 2011, installation view

Not surprisingly, Chilton hails from one of the coastal states, and he's been picked-up and shown on the opposite coast. In spite of what happened in architecture and furniture design after pollination by the Bauhaus in the 1930s (and maybe in needful opposition to it) geometric abstraction in painting did not take root and flower in Chicago as it did in other places.[9] The easily imagined art historical precedents for Chilton and Stack's linear work, collected and exhibited in Chicago, tend to have been trucked-in from New York or some part of Western Europe. For example, Frank Stella and Barnett Newman hail from New York, Bridget Riley from England, and Sean Scully from Ireland.[10]

Maybe, playing upon the reference to the Weimar Republic in the preceding paragraph, Chilton and Stack are equally out of step with the "zeitgeist" in Chicago. Here and now, economic theory (Marx and Engels are only rarely named) underpins much contemporary education, production, and critique within the visual arts; and, not surprisingly, types of social art, poor art and street art constitute no small part of the local scene. Specialization in a particular craft, solitary studio work, and the production of real "commodities," such as the oil paintings on canvas made by Chilton and Stack, are things broadly considered to be passe.[11] For Scott Stack not to be connected to Todd Chilton's youthful cohort of SAIC and UIC graduates is a yet-more difficult thing. Whether Chilton will become more like Stack, or Stack more like Chilton, time will tell...

+ + +

Notes:

[1] http://paulgermanos.blogspot.com/2011/10/preview-scott-stack-monique-meloche.html

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gestalt_psychology

[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hermann_Rorschach

[4] http://www.cod.edu/gallery/catalog/short_stack.pdf
Paragraph Two: "between representation and abstraction an approach to painting has developed that one might describe as 'situational,' a conceptually based attitude toward the application of paint,"

Above: Essay by Dominic Molon, past Pamela Alper Associate Curator, Museum of Contemporary Art, Chicago
"Situational Painting: Matthew Girson, Scott Short, Scott Stack"
May 19 - June 23, 2005
Gahlberg Gallery
College of DuPage
Glen Ellyn, Illinois

[5] Ibid.

Paragraph Six: "The skewed view of the world presented to us through electronic mediation is examined in the paintings of Scott Stack,"

Paragraph Six: "Stack’s depiction of scenes comprising shadowy forms often seen through some type of electronic distortion makes the more sinister implications of a life lived through televised, filmed or computer-based mediation (such as the use of media as a form of social control) visually manifest in his paintings,"

[6] http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2006-03-31/entertainment/0603310296_1_peter-miller-gallery-drawings-cover
"His first approach was to give contemporary scenes culled from newspaper photographs the look of having been viewed through night-vision goggles. So the images are horizontally striated..."

Above: Alan G. Artner, Chicago Tribune art critic, March 31, 2006, "Scott Stack at the Monique Meloche Gallery"

***Artner seems to suggest that Stack entered linear abstraction through the relatively straightforward representation of a technological distortion.***

[7] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fernand_Leger
Above: See "The Railway Crossing," 1919, noting stochastic arrangement of well-modeled diagonal lines.

See also: http://www.artic.edu/aic/collections/artwork/79600

[8] Todd Chilton appeared in both the 2006 and also 2010 iterations of the contemporary formal exhibition "Ps & Qs," as curated by Shannon Stratton and Jeff Ward.

2010: http://www.hydeparkart.org/exhibitions/ps-qs-1
Review: http://art.newcity.com/2010/03/22/review-ps-qshyde-park-art-center/

2006: http://microrevolt.org/reblog/archives/2006/09/ps-qs.html
Above: Todd Chilton, Nevin Tomlinson, Andrea Myers, Kirsten Flanigan, Mung Lar Lam, Paul Jackson, Carl Suddath, Katy Heinlein
September 8 - November 12, 2006
Glassell School of Art
Museum of Fine Arts, Houston

Todd Chilton appeared in both "Beautiful Form" and "New Formalisms 2" as curated by Abraham Ritchie, in 2009 and 2012 respectively.

Samantha Bittman & Todd Chilton @ 65GRAND
Above: Todd Chilton with Samantha Bittman in "New Formalisms 2," on January 13, 2012, at 65GRAND, 1369 W. Grand Ave., Chicago, IL 60642

2012: http://65grand.com/newformalisms2_release.php
Review: http://art.newcity.com/2012/01/31/review-new-formalisms-2-65grand/

2009: http://www.65grand.com/beautiful_form_release.php
Review: http://art.newcity.com/2009/01/19/review-beautiful-form65-grand/

[9] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludwig_Mies_van_der_Rohe
Above: See Illinois Institute of Technology, Second Chicago School, International Modernism, and Walter Gropius

[10] http://www.artic.edu/aic/collections/artwork/72177
Above: Sean Scully, "Heart of Darkness," 1982, oil on canvas, 96 x 144 inches

Scully was shown (and, if memory serves, afforded a great deal of space) at The Art Institute of Chicago, December 15, 1987 – February 7, 1988

[11] A Feminist critique of Chilton and Stack might additionally emphasize the artists maintenance of an essentially patriarchal narrative; the commercial, as opposed to domestic, context of the artists' exhibitions; the subordination and anonymity of familial support structures enabling each male artist; etc. Multiculturalists might find fault with Chilton and Stack when considering the narrow ethnic demographic which the two artists represent. Chicago Imagists, i.e., Surrealists, their collectors and chroniclers, not Marxists, Feminists, or multiculturalists, find little to love in any form of non-objective geometric abstraction. And, Neo-Conceptualists seem to occupy little intellectual ground apart from Marxism and Feminism.

+ + +

Exhibitions:

Todd Chilton
October 28 - December 3, 2011
Rhona Hoffman Gallery
118 North Peoria Street
Chicago, Illinois 60607
http://www.rhoffmangallery.com/

Scott Stack
October 15 – November 12, 2011
Monique Meloche Gallery
2154 W. Division
Chicago, Illinois 60622
http://moniquemeloche.com/

+ + +

Related Posts:

http://paulgermanos.blogspot.com/2011/07/editorial-after-minimalism-in-chicago.html
"Editorial: After Minimalism in Chicago the Summer of 2011," July 22, 2011

http://paulgermanos.blogspot.com/2010/09/review-todd-chilton-slow.html
"Review: Todd Chilton @ Slow," September 9, 2010

- Paul Germanos

Thursday, October 13, 2011

Preview: Scott Stack @ Monique Meloche

"I'm not interested in pure green, or pure red, or anything straight out of the tube," he said, "That's not color." All 'round us, punchy near-primary hues popped vividly into focus; Oak Park's autumnal display of foliage was especially glorious that sunny October afternoon. There, in the garden which girdled his home and studio, Scott Stack proceeded to search through the green leaves and red leaves till he found one which was in chromatic transition.

Scott Stack Preview Monique Meloche

"Do you see?" Stack queried, then pronounced: "That's color." And I was reminded that two years ago, when first I met Stack in Monique Meloche's gallery, his painting seemed to be the thing in transition:

Scott Stack @ moniquemeloche
Above: Scott Stack @ Monique Meloche, March 20, 2009

In 2009, Scott Stack appeared to straddle the opposing islands of representation and geometric abstraction; and which would prove to be the more enduring ground was then wholly unknown. In 2011, moving from the garden exterior to the studio interior, I was shocked to learn that every (easily recognizable) trace of the figure, architecture and landscape had vanished from his paintings:

Scott Stack Preview Monique Meloche
Above: Scott Stack outside his Oak Park studio, October 9, 2011
Scott Stack Preview Monique Meloche
Above: Stack's studio doors swung open
Scott Stack Preview Monique Meloche
Above: Scott Stack in studio, in 2011

Linear devices, which once were only ancillary, had grown in importance: becoming the building blocks of his compositions. In the new work, 10mm bands of oil-suspended pigment were arranged and blended on carefully-smoothed, well-gessoed cloth, so that "direction" and the illusion of three-dimensional space were indicated therein apart from any identifiable light source and corresponding shading.

Scott Stack Preview Monique Meloche
Above: Edge detail of new (2010-2011) painting
Scott Stack @ moniquemeloche
Above: Scott Stack with painting in 2009

During the studio visit, Stack spoke in an animated manner about the deconstruction and reconstruction of real physical structures, surveillance technology, war and the popular media portrayal thereof. The subtext of violence which informed his Pop sensibility linked him yet more closely, in my mind, to Ed Paschke--whose (figure) work from the 1980s, e.g., "Tempext," "Torrita," "Coupe Faim," "George Mills," I remembered too as hinging formally upon elements of linear abstraction. Paschke was thirteen years senior to Stack.

Scott Stack Preview Monique Meloche
Above: Stack explains process in studio, 2011

It's interesting to see things change--to see things become more sophisticated and refined--over time. Anne Wilson is now in her 60s; Barbara Kasten is in her 70s; they're both producing great work. As he leaves his 50s, Scott Stack has taken a massive leap forward with these new (2010-2011) paintings. It's worth stopping at the opening:

Saturday, October 15, 2011, from 4:00PM to 7:00PM
moniquemeloche gallery, 2154 W. Division Street
Chicago, IL 60622

Scott Stack Preview Monique Meloche
Above: Stack's brushes

Scott Stack: "City of the Future," runs through November 12, 2011. A talk with his fellow "Oak Parker" Michelle Grabner is scheduled to take place in the gallery on Saturday, November 12, 2011, at 1:00PM.

http://moniquemeloche.com

- Paul Germanos

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Pictorial: Kendell Carter @ Monique Meloche

Kendell Carter @ Monique Meloche

Kendell Carter @ Monique Meloche

Kendell Carter @ Monique Meloche

Kendell Carter @ Monique Meloche

Kendell Carter @ Monique Meloche

Kendell Carter @ Monique Meloche

Kendell Carter @ Monique Meloche

Kendell Carter in:
Liberation Summer
May 21 – July 30, 2011
moniquemeloche gallery
2154 W. Division
Chicago, IL 60622
http://moniquemeloche.com

- Paul Germanos

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Review: Rinus Van de Velde @ Monique Meloche

Immediately, the exhibition suggests a visual precedent: the work of Raymond Pettibon. The young artist (aged 27 years) is familiar with, but not overly fatigued by, the reference. And rather than rejecting the comparison outright, he strives in English to suggest a nuanced distinction between himself and the Black Flag conspirator. "Pettibon," says Rinus, "really is more of a painter."

Rinus Van de Velde @ Monique Meloche
Above: Rinus Van de Velde, candid.

Rinus Van de Velde draws. And where Pettibon is often found dripping in his wet work, Van de Velde's charcoal and papers are dry.  So, it seems at first easy to nod in agreement with Rinus' self-assessment. But, Pettibon is (usually) remarkable in his use of line, while in contrast Van de Velde produces value studies almost exclusively through skillful shading and blending. The former artist is actually the more "graphic" of the two.

Rinus Van de Velde @ Monique Meloche

Van de Velde, if not a painter, is deeply connected to the illusion of volume at which painters once aimed; especially noteworthy is the concomitant use of chiaroscuro. Yet again, though he begins with two-dimensional (digital) source material, Van de Velde is manifestly preoccupied with the rendition of a three-dimensional presence in a two-dimensional space. Towards that end, like a "real" painter, Van de Velde relies upon gradients and not linear work, e.g., cross-hatching or outlining, in order to suggest a given form. It's easy to believe that he began his training as a sculptor.

Rinus Van de Velde @ Monique Meloche

All of this omits the text. Rinus is given pause when asked about Barbara Kruger and Jenny Holzer. "I'll need to think about that," he responds. Kruger in particular seems good to mention as she furiously packs (virtually) all of the space between her images with text; like Van de Velde, both women (Kruger and Holzer) "write" directly upon architectural surfaces.

Rinus Van de Velde @ Monique Meloche

Returning to the beginning, it's the indication of the artist's own hand which not only draws Van de Velde close to Pettibon but which also distances him from Kruger's bold italic, and Holzer's electric, font. There's his hatching: in the writing. Different than any of them, Van de Velde's textual "ground" manifests as a fantastic sort of "stream of consciousness" monologue which, maybe akin to Joyce's "commodius vicus of recirculation," really goes nowhere.

Whether there is (ever) a progression towards meaning, this artist's "found" JPEG reinterpretations are buoyed along in a manner which is pleasing to behold...

Rinus Van de Velde in:
Dear David Johnson,
April 2 – May 14, 2011
moniquemeloche
2154 W. Division
Chicago IL 60622
http://moniquemeloche.com

- Paul Germanos

Monday, March 28, 2011

Pictorial: Barbara Kasten

Barbara Kasten @ 845 W. Washington

Above: Barbara Kasten, audio-visual installation
Remix, with Lucky Dragons
March 12 – May 31, 2011
Applied Arts
845 W. Washington
Chicago, IL 60607
http://barbarakasten.net

See also: Barbara Kasten's Remix treated in the company of recent video works by Ben Russell, Eric Fleischauer, and Nicolas Grospierre, as found within the article Eye Exam: Stand in the Light, by Jason Foumberg of Newcity Art,
http://art.newcity.com/2011/03/28/eye-exam-stand-in-the-light/

Barbara Kasten @ Monique Meloche

Above: Barbara Kasten, photographic print
Group show including works by Karl Haendel, Walead Beshty and Sheree Hovsepian
March 20 – May 15, 2010 (one year ago)
Monique Meloche
2154 W. Division
Chicago, IL 60622
http://moniquemeloche.com

- Paul Germanos

Monday, March 21, 2011

Editorial: Winter Experiment @ Monique Meloche & Discussion in Chicago

It's an act of "munificence" to throw open the doors of one's own home or place of business and invite in strangers for a symposium; and it's an act of "magnanimity" to restore the quarters without complaint in the wake of such an event. The naming of virtue here is easily dismissed as weirdly archaic or, worse, sycophantic. However, in truth, the wheel of art and the progress of culture depend almost wholly upon the regular exercise of generosity and grace.

Not the "Symposium" but rather Plato's "Republic" begins with his character of Socrates remembering a descent to the Piraeus.[1] It was the lowly Piraeus, in its function as the port of Athens, from which novel and foreign things tended to be made available to his (Socrates') high city. And philosophy, as an expression of the longing for knowledge in the true sense, depended upon Socrates' willingness to move and look precisely there: beyond the familiar.

Ebony G. Patterson @ Monique Meloche
Ebony G. Patterson in the Winter Experiment

Between January 15 and February 5, 2011, the "Winter Experiment" was played out within gallery moniquemeloche.[2] In order of appearance, Ebony G. Patterson, Dan Gunn, Ben Fain, and Anna Shteynshleyger built installations within the space: each person in succession staging the scene for his or her own Saturday afternoon interview, followed immediately by a week-long exhibition of artwork.

It might seem a great leap from "The Republic" to the "Winter Experiment," so that it would be natural to wonder about the connection between the second and third paragraphs of this article. Such a relationship as might exist is dependent upon one's willingness to accept that the gallery (any good gallery) has the potential to function within Chicago in a manner which is comparable to the Piraeus in its relation to Athens, i.e., a place in which the novel and foreign are likely to appear.

Those who went down, here, found within each week's installment: artwork; a pairing of artist and interlocutor; other spectators; and members of the gallery staff. Taken together, the aforementioned elements of the "Winter Experiment" were said to constitute not a "traditional" commercial show but rather a community engagement. And curiously (given the context) the element of visual art might well have been only ancillary to the human interaction ongoing in its vicinity. Encouraging consideration of that possibility (the subordination of the visual to the auditory) is evidence found in the one other "Winter Experiment" article yet published. The young Erik Wenzel, Senior ArtSlant Staff Writer, recalled in text a singular visit which he made during the event's second weekly convocation.[3] Therein, Wenzel chose to employ twenty (cumulative) repetitions of the words: converse or conversation, dialogue, talk, discussion and discourse.[4]

Dan Gunn @ Monique Meloche
Dan Gunn in the Winter Experiment

In contrast, no word related to the visual properties of an artwork--such as color, line, shape, texture, scale, proportion--ever appeared in the (Wenzel) piece on ArtSlant; not even the broad categories of painting, drawing, video, and photography, each present in the "Winter Experiment," were invoked.[5] The artwork "said" nothing so important to Erik Wenzel (or any other local writer) that he felt the need to repeat it. Is that in itself noteworthy? If so, is it telling of the writer(s), the engagement, or the material on display?

The artwork hung silently in the gallery during Wenzel's visit; an image of the artwork appeared without comment in Wenzel's article; the artwork seen by Wenzel was made by someone said to have experience building theater props. Maybe it (visual art) is now expected to serve as support for speeches, and nothing else.  Having written that, it would be imprudent to rush towards a particular conclusion.

In fact, the boundaries of the "Winter Experiment" were not fixed but rather they expanded and contracted according to the number and activity of all participants--continuing, perhaps, to the reading of this text. The position, the movement, of the general public seems therefore important--in "relation" to the whole of the experience. To what, and to whom, did Chicago respond in this case? Why?

Ben Fain @ Monique Meloche
Ben Fain in the Winter Experiment

Were the attendance of the "Winter Experiment" to be graphed it would take a bell-shaped form: climbing from the first week to peak in the second and third weeks, falling again in the fourth and final week. What might have affected the attendance? The time and location of the event remained the same from week-to-week, and so ought not to have been a factor. The event could only have become better known over time, so that the last week should have enjoyed the largest audience; it did not. The weather did vary from January 15 to February 5; but, being Winter in Chicago, it (the weather) was never especially good.

Anna Shteynshleyger @ Monique Meloche
Anna Shteynshleyger in the Winter Experiment

Critically, in retrospect it seems that the strongest correlation proved to be between that which was familiar to the people and that which the people came to see. Those parties (pairings of artist and interlocutor) who in sum had the greatest presence in what is called the Chicago art community--Dan Gunn and Michelle Grabner in the second week and Ben Fain and Shannon Stratton in the third week--drew the largest numbers.[6] The chance of sighting the novel and foreign did not in the end seem equal to the motivation provided by association, habit, and self-interest. Remembering the second paragraph above, such patterns, seen repeated elsewhere and over time, are worrisome.

"Discussion," "dialogue," and even "dialectic," all presuppose the competent articulation of multiple, relevant ideas. And, ever more frequently, one is made to wonder whether the new psychological monolith of "community" has hampered both the outward movement of its members and also the inward movement of the bearers of the counterargument. It's a bit of a game of semantics: while the words (above listed, such as "discussion") continue to circulate, that which they are thought to represent in speech has changed over time in the world of action. Even so, teasing out the tandem smothering deaths of philosophy and art, by means of the analysis of one critical blurb and one pattern of attendance, might be something more than melodramatic. It seems very much more realistic to begin by wondering in what form "high culture" was ever alive within the visual arts here, as some have implied that it has suffered only maltreatment from its inception.

Ben Fain @ Monique Meloche
Ben Fain video in the Winter Experiment

While explaining the struggle and eventual failure of the publication "New Art Examiner" in relation to Chicago's perpetual "Second City" status, Derek Guthrie suggested in his 2008 Bad at Sports interview that: "We [Guthrie et al] were on the wrong side of the anti-intellectual machine that runs this city, and Chicago will never be an art center as until such times, and I don't care if three Picassos are born next week, it will never happen until we start having discourse and discourse just means that you have discussion..."[7]

Following Guthrie, in the listener comments which were able to be appended to that interview at the time of its airing, Mark Staff Brandl concurred: "[...] I think he is mostly dead-on about Chicago. Certainly, that 'anti-intellectualism' he fought has now been replaced with a strange pseudo-intellectualism, yet it all remains structurally the same with new masters, mistresses: bigoted machinations of those who have petty close-mindedness. An approach stifling [sp.] dialogue and having all the negative effects exactly as Derek outlined them, with the added bonus of hypocrisy."[8]

Not a smothering death per se, but both Guthrie and also Brandl wished to suggest that a (using Brandl's word) "stifling" of much local growth is to be expected, given Chicago's intellectual climate. Returning to the original subject, the "Winter Experiment" did in every case formally pair its young artists with relatively sympathetic questioners in order to more readily elicit thoughtful responses from them. But, when viewed across the four-week period for which it ran, the "Winter Experiment" did also include a broad range of artists and questioners; it was, after all, meant to introduce new things. If the generalized (poor) response of the "Chicago art community" to the things outside of itself (the novel and foreign, not to mention the rebuttal or counterargument, etc.) is at issue, are the references (above) to an "anti-intellectual machine," and "masters, mistresses," an indication that the quotations from Guthrie and Brandl are irrelevant? Or, are there both top-down and also a bottom-up relationships--maybe not unlike the political symbiosis between an apathetic public and manipulative officeholders--which are equally needful of consideration?

Claudine Ise in Crisis-Free Arts Criticism Salon @ threewalls
Claudine Ise in Crisis-Free Arts Criticism

One year after Guthrie's interview the ability to directly append comments (such as Brandl's) to articles was removed from the Bad at Sports website.[9] Public participation (at Bad at Sports) is now channeled via e-mail (or phone call?) through the blog's editors, whom might or might not post all of the submitted text in some place of their choosing. It appears to be the case that, to date, one comment has passed through said system to become seen.[10] And only (Bad at Sports) members, or guests invited by members, now find participation possible. Monologue was facilitated; dialogue was inhibited; metaphorically, the wagons were circled.

Per Bad at Sports' audio hosts Richard Holland and Duncan MacKenzie, California natives Meg Onli (moved to Chicago in 2005) and Claudine Isé (moved to Chicago in 2008) now manage the group's on-line writing. And with regard to "discussion," Onli and Isé named the finest of the past year (2010) as, "Studio Chicago, a yearlong collaborative project focusing on the artist’s studio."[11] Self-identified as "Core Partners," the "Studio Chicago" members--Chicago Department of Cultural Affairs, Columbia College Chicago, DePaul University Museum, Gallery 400 at UIC, Hyde Park Art Center, Museum of Contemporary Art, School of the Art Institute of Chicago, and threewalls--in turn named the "Studio Chicago Blog" as their "forum for discussion."[12]

Crisis-Free Arts Criticism Salon @ threewalls
Crisis-Free Arts Criticism Salon in threewalls

In a familiar pattern, over the one-year life of "Studio Chicago," its, (a) Core Partners invited guests to post the "Studio Chicago Blog" for a period of one week; (b) guest posts were subject to moderation by Core Partners; and (c) comments deemed inappropriate and/or off-topic were removed at the Core Partner's discretion.[13] In short: control was (again) exercised or reserved to be exercised over every aspect of the "Studio Chicago" discussion component. Did that control serve a necessary purpose (removal of threat, libel, etc.) only; or, upon close examination, might parties, e.g., Guthrie and Brandl, reasonably suggest that the exclusion of some viewpoints inhibited the "life" of what's properly called discussion? How might it be possible to begin to consider whether any given control is editorial or censorial?

Between October of 2009 and October of 2010, 59 "Studio Chicago Blog" entries were produced through the combined efforts of eight major (and minor) organizational players in Chicago's visual culture; they included 1 introductory post and 58 pieces of content.[14] According to some criteria, gender for example, a great effort to "balance" the writers appears to have been made. Noting that some of the 58 pieces of content had multiple authors, and that some of those authors contributed on more than one occasion: 28 posts had female authors and 26 posts had male authors.[15] While not proportional to Chicago's demographics, with regard to race and ethnicity too an attempt at inclusion seems evident. But in other areas the evidence tells a different story.

Lori Waxman in Crisis-Free Arts Criticism Salon @ threewalls
Lori Waxman (background, at left) in Crisis-Free Arts Criticism

"Studio Chicago" was, manifestly, a demonstration of privilege attendant to "community," i.e., acceptance into one or more of Chicago's many organizations. Only very few--if any--of the chosen posters might not have had an affiliation with an academic institution, co-operative, not-for-profit, government entity, or other such group.[16] "Studio Chicago," in spite of what its name might have been thought to imply, was not an opportunity for individual visual artists to share the details of what transpired in their studio in Chicago. Whether one was an artist, occupied a physical studio, created tangible objects, or had any longstanding connection to the city was largely irrelevant. "Studio Chicago" leveled the distinctions between artists and curators, art making and social action, the visual and theatrical arts, one place on the globe and any other place on the globe. From the onset it was taken as given that "art" and a "studio" might equally well be any one of a number of things--meaning that many of the chief questions were answered by the Core Partners before being known to the public.[17] The cumulative effect was to lionize the collective, the egalitarian, the non-traditional, and the anti-commodity. Where was the oversight? Where were Chicago's critics?

Pedro Velez in Crisis-Free Arts Criticism Salon @ threewalls
Pedro Velez in Crisis-Free Arts Criticism

Independent of "Studio Chicago," on March 1, 2011, former "Core Partner" threewalls hosted "Crisis-Free Arts Criticism,"[18] which was called a public discussion. Arts writers Jason Foumberg, Claudine Isé, Lori Waxman, and Pedro Veléz, were invited to lead a conversation which addressed the widespread perception of "an apparently ceaseless 'crisis of criticism,'" in Chicago.[19] Jason Foumberg declined.[20] And threewalls' representative Ania Szremski was left to guide the remaining three figures.[21]

Given that in staging the event Szremski/threewalls had acknowledged the existence of a broadly held, long-term concern with arts writing in Chicago, only to then dismiss that concern as "insecurity," it seemed noteworthy that all of the invited leads were invested in the status quo,[22] and had previously demonstrated support for one another or the position of Szremski/threewalls.[23] It was so very noteworthy that after the introduction of "Crisis-Free Arts Criticism" had been completed, and the floor opened for the first question, Szremski was asked directly why no representative of the counterargument had been invited.[24] First acknowledging the pre-existing consensus, Szremski went on to explain that the counterargument was excluded because, "We wanted this to be a productive discussion."[25] Considering the potential meaning of that response it would be good to wonder: Productive of what?

Ania Szremski in Crisis-Free Arts Criticism Salon @ threewalls
Ania Szremski in Crisis-Free Arts Criticism

For those who have hoped to participate in an unfettered exchange of ideas--whether in speech, or in text, or in visual form--the situation in Chicago does at times seem less than ideal. Where the novel and foreign have been made available, the "Chicago art community" has seemed not moved to look. And where the representatives of the counterargument have been willing to move and participate, the "Chicago art community" has seemed to "wall them out." If not all things are good to see, and not all speech is helpful, how should the good and the helpful be known apart from a thoughtful consideration of the whole, in which the evidence and arguments--for one thing and against another thing--are seen and heard. We depend upon our questions, as much as any answer, to better know the truth. Models of "practice" which rely upon unquestioning belief and partisan action have the effect of pushing art towards the realms of religion and politics. And that's dangerous ground, especially when public money is used to support the activity.

[1] http://classics.mit.edu/Plato/republic.2.i.html

[2] http://moniquemeloche.com/winter-experiment-2011/

[3] http://www.artslant.com/chi/articles/show/21264
Above: "Winter Experiment," by Erik Wenzel, ArtSlant, January 24, 2011
[4] Ibid.
[5] Ibid.

[6] Witnessed by author; confirmed by gallery staff.
Full "Winter Experiment" 2011 schedule:
January 15: Ebony G. Patterson & Tumelo Mosaka
January 22: Dan Gunn & Michelle Grabner
January 29: Ben Fain & Shannon Stratton
February 5: Anna Shteynshleyger & Andreas Waldburg-Wolfegg

[7] http://badatsports.com/2008/episode-168-derek-guthrie/
Above: Hear Derek Guthrie in original "podcast" audio from 40:00-40:29, November 16, 2008, Episode 168: Derek Guthrie
[8] Ibid.
Above: Comment (in text) appended by Mark Staff Brandl, November 19th, 2008

[9] http://badatsports.com/2010/letter-to-the-editor-britton-bertran/
Above: In response to "Letter to the Editor," by Britton Bertran, May 2, 2010, Meg Onli wrote that, "[...] we [Bad at Sports] removed comments with the new site launch on November 1st, 2009"
[10] Ibid.

[11] http://blog.art21.org/2010/12/31/center-field-art-in-the-middle-with-bad-at-sports-top-10-chicago-art-events-in-2010/
Above: Meg Onli and Claudine Isé, December 31, 2010: "Best city-wide, sustained, multi-platform discussion of a single topic in contemporary art: Studio Chicago..."

[12] http://www.studiochicago.org/

[13] http://studiochicago.blogspot.com/
[14] Ibid.

[15] Full "Studio Chicago Blog" posting schedule:
October 26, 2009: Barbara Koenen
November 4, 2009: Philip von Zweck
November 16, 2009: Michelle Grabner
November 23, 2009: Jacqueline Terrassa
December 1, 2009: Joyce Owens
December 7, 2009: Kevin Henry
December 14, 2009: Jim Duignan
December 21, 2009: David Moré
December 29, 2009: Abigail Satinsky
January 4, 2010: Dominic Molon
January 11, 2010: Mathew Paul Jinks
January 18, 2010: Karsten Lund
January 25, 2010: Lisa Stone
February 1, 2010: Katie Hawkey Swindler
February 8, 2010: Sarah Laing
February 15, 2010: Rey Colón
February 22, 2010: Abdul Goler
March 1, 2010: Brian Tyler Wright
March 8, 2010: Jon Cates
March 15, 2010: Diana Nawi
March 22, 2010: Stan Chisholm
March 29, 2010: Arti Sandhu
April 5, 2010: Beth Wiedner and Faiz Razi
April 12, 2010: Jessica Hutchinson
April 19, 2010: Irena Knezevic
April 20, 2010: Irena Knezevic
April 22, 2010: Irena Knezevic
May 3, 2010: John Neff
May 5, 2010: John Neff
May 11, 2010: Sze Lin Pang
May 17, 2010: Thea Liberty Nichols
May 24, 2010: Adam Brooks and Mathew Wilson
May 31, 2010: Sara Schnadt
June 7, 2010: Angee Lennard
June 10, 2010: Angee Lennard
June 15, 2010: Jessica Cochran
June 23, 2010: Jessica Cochran
June 23, 2010: Maggie Leininger
June 30, 2010: Jennifer Geigel Mikulay
July 6, 2010: Judd Morrissey and Mark Jeffery
July 21, 2010: D. Denenge Akpem
July 28, 2010: W. Keith Brown
August 2, 2010: W. Keith Brown
August 2, 2010: W. Keith Brown
August 4, 2010: Melissa Stanley
August 12, 2010: Adia Millett
August 19, 2010: Cauleen Smith
August 25, 2010: Annie Heckman
September 1, 2010: Adam Grossi
September 8, 2010: Shane Aslan Selzer
September 13, 2010: Elissa Papendick and Libby O’Bryan
September 15, 2010: Louise LeBourgeoise
September 22, 2010: Nicolette Michele Caldwell
September 29, 2010: Zach Dodson
October 6, 2010: Alberto Aguilar
October 13, 2010: Peter Fagundo
October 20, 2010: Chad Kouri
October 27, 2010: Conrad Freiburg

[16] See:
InCUBATE
Stockyard Institute
Industry of the Ordinary
Green Lantern
The Post Family
ARTivention
Open Studio Project Inc.
Bad at Sports
Spudnik Press Cooperative
Chicago State University
School of The Art Institute of Chicago
Harold Washington College
Columbia College Chicago
Hyde Park Art Center
Museum of Contemporary Art
threewalls
Alverno College (Milwaukee)
DePaul University Museum
City of Chicago
Gallery 400 at UIC

[17] http://studiochicago.blogspot.com/2009/11/introductory-thoughts-on-studio.html
Above: Paul Klein and Wesley Kimler attempted to voice their objections after the November 4, 2009, post. Neither Klein, nor Kimler, nor any representative of their position, i.e., the counterargument, ever wrote an invited post in the "Studio Chicago Blog."

See also: http://www.chicagoreader.com/chicago/kimlers-complaint/Content?oid=896646
Above: "Kimler's Complaint" in "The Reader" for a lengthier treatment of the issue.

[18] http://badatsports.com/2011/threewallssalon-crisis-free-art-criticism-discussion-tonight/
[19] Ibid.

[20] Author witnessed same reported at the event.
[21] Ibid.

[22] See:
Claudine Isé: artforum.com, Bad at Sports, Art21 Blog
Lori Waxman: Artforum, Bad at Sports, Chicago Tribune
Pedro Veléz: artnet.com

[23] http://badatsports.com/2009/forget-the-olympics-what-the-second-city-really-needs-is-first-class-art-news/
Above: Claudine Isé, October 5, 2009: "My advice to the Trib: get freelancer Lori Waxman on staff and make her a reporter or something–I don’t fucking care..."

http://badatsports.com/2009/episode-177-art-journalism/
Above: Pedro Veléz, January 19, 2009: "There’s more than enough art criticism in Chicago. and has been that way for a long time..."

http://studiochicago.blogspot.com/2009/11/introductory-thoughts-on-studio.html
Above: Pedro Veléz in response to Paul Klein's questions, November 9, 2009: "...This obsessive Jihad against everything you guys don't agree with is pathetic."

http://www.artnet.com/magazineus/reviews/velez/2010-chicago-review1-13-11.asp
Above: Pedro Veléz on Ania Szremski in "Chicago 2010" on artnet.com: "Academic art writing--criticism, theory and opinion--is well served in the city. Whitney Stoepel and Ania Szremski collaborate with F News Magazine..."

http://www.artnet.com/magazineus/reviews/velez/2010-chicago-review1-13-11_detail.asp?picnum=19
See also image above.

http://60wrdmin.org/resume
http://www.shannonstratton.com/curriculum-vitae/
Above: Lori Waxman, "Shannon Stratton," artforum.com "Critic’s Picks" April 30, 2008.
(Shannon Stratton is Director of threewalls.)

http://www.three-walls.org/store/publications/
Above: Lori Waxman's writing for sale on-line at threewalls' store in the texts, "Talking With Your Mouth Full: New Language For Socially Engaged Art" and, "Artists Run Chicago Digest"

[24] Author put the question to Ania Szremski.

[25] Author witnessed same reported at the event.

Questions:

- Might the fullest possible development of any one role within the arts, i.e., "expertise," have come to be inhibited by the division of time and effort between the multiple roles presupposed by the vogue "constellation of practices" model?

- Might the coincidental mushrooming of the "art blog" and the "apartment gallery" have practically eliminated all qualitative entry barriers both to exhibition and also to the interpretation and/or promotion thereof?

- Might the relatively new on-line social networks, e.g., Twitter and Facebook, have tended to reinforce "communitarian" thought and behavior?

- Within the arts specifically, might the increasingly young age, and corresponding inexperience, of most "role players" hamper sound judgment?

- Might the fear of social sanction have grown in relation to the broadly perceived need to "network" rather than work in isolation, further inhibiting frank exchange and honest evaluation among critics and curators?

- Might the "new" political rhetoric as exercised within (recently ascendant) Chicago have tended to incorporate youthful, majoritarian, and social justice themes?

- Might the economic deterioration of Illinois have heightened at least the perception that there is little compensation available in exchange for most arts activity, increasing the incentive to play yet more "roles" in employment outside of the arts?

- Might the possibility of careful, studio-based, object production have diminished as a result of the real growth of both "social practice" and also what is known as a "constellation of practices" model?

- Might the chronic exclusion of the counterargument and the minority position from "discussions," given all of the above, have come to be generally accepted as a social good?[26]

[26] Author attempted to introduce the questions above at "Crisis-Free Arts Criticism," and was then named in public a "debaser," by attendee Easton Miller.

- Paul Germanos

Pictorial: Ebony G. Patterson @ Monique Meloche

Ebony G. Patterson @ Monique Meloche

Ebony G. Patterson @ Monique Meloche

Ebony G. Patterson @ Monique Meloche

Ebony G. Patterson
February 12 - March 26, 2011
moniquemeloche gallery
2154 W. Division
Chicago, IL 60622
http://moniquemeloche.com

- Paul Germanos

Sunday, September 19, 2010

Review: Carla Arocha & Stephane Schraenen @ Monique Meloche

Anish Kapoor's "Cloud Gate" is well-loved in Chicago.  Its polished, stainless steel skin reflects not only the City skyline but also those spectators near to the curvilinear work, thus providing equal opportunity for civic pride and public vanity--assuming that they are distinguishable.[1]

Anish Kapoor: Cloud Gate
Above: Anish Kapoor's "Cloud Gate"

In a similar manner, for the purpose of examining their own reflections, patrons (including the author) drew close to the mirror-like surfaces contained within four pieces of statuary on display at the opening of Carla Arocha and Stephane Schraenen's show "As if" at Monique Meloche Gallery.

Carla Arocha & Stephane Schraenen @ Monique Meloche
Above: Carla Arocha and Stephane Schraenen's "Untitled (gold)" which, on a different scale, would fit quite nicely into Chicago's skyline.  See MvdR's 1971 IBM Building,[2] which Ira J. Bach called, "superbly proportioned."[3]

It was a human response, likely engendered by the scale and proportion (59 x 20 x 12 inches in every case) of the art.[4]  The bright, acrylic sheets filling each sculpture were said to have been laser-cut; the monolithic cabinets holding that acrylic were said to have been fastidiously constructed from synthetic board painted with automobile enamel.  But, contrary to the orchestrated precision which characterized the process of the artworks' fabrication, it was that random, casual, and natural reaction of the audience which provided the color--according to the (reflected) dress of the attendee.  What seemed at first proper to judge as a minimal and nearly monochromatic presentation of regular, geometric forms was enlivened by the entry of the crowd.

Carla Arocha & Stephane Schraenen @ Monique Meloche
Above: Carla Arocha and Stephane Schraenen's "Untitled (lines)"

Visual art is "alive" when it's seen, in real time and space, by an engaged party.  And, generally, it's fatal to understanding to imagine that artworks (any cultural products) exist only in the vacuum of "white cube" gallery and museum spaces.  Hopefully, internet viewership and academic practice--being abstracted from reality--will not wholly displace the pursuit of direct experience and the practice of personal contemplation.  How much color is in Arocha and Schraenen's show? as much or as little color as is in the environment in which it's displayed.  Light, clothing, paint on the walls: The pieces are affected by whatever surrounds them.

Carla Arocha & Stephane Schraenen @ Monique Meloche
Above: Carla Arocha and Stephane Schraenen's"Untitled (bubbles)"

On perception: The gallery's front window and front wall (facing Division) have been treated with precisely-cut vinyl tape, so that two concentric ring patterns are held on planes parallel to one another, separated by a distance of roughly two meters.  As viewed from the sidewalk and/or street, a "moire" effect appears in a striking manner.  The high contrast of the black and white, figure and ground, is boldly graphic.  But the piece is truly three-dimensional (sculpture) as its appreciation depends upon spatial relationships.  It's from this installation that the show takes its title; and it's probably the most effective use of the storefront to date.

Carla Arocha & Stephane Schraenen @ Monique Meloche
Above: Carla Arocha and Stephane Schraenen's "As if"

The whole show--installation, statuary, and four photographic prints--seems very much more expansive than it is, thanks to good placement and light.

[1] Anish Kapoor's "Cloud Gate" is curvilinear in shape--but contains within its surface the reflections of many rectilinear shapes as a result of the context in which it has been placed.

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/330_North_Wabash
Above: Mies van der Rohe's 1971 IBM Building at 330 N. Wabash

[3] "Chicago's Famous Buildings" Third Edition, ed. Ira J. Bach (1965, 1969; Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1980) 95-96.

[4] If the scale and the proportion (but not the shape) of Arocha & Schraenen's statuary relates to the human body, in the context of Chicago the shape and proportion (if not the scale) of that statuary relates to the City's Modern architecture.

Carla Arocha & Stephane Schraenen
"As if"
September 16 – November 6, 2010
Tuesday – Saturday, 11:00 am - 6:00 pm
Closed Sunday and Monday
Monique Meloche Gallery
2154 W. Division (@ Leavitt)
Chicago, IL 60622
http://moniquemeloche.com

See also: Lauren Weinberg's Time Out Chicago review of Carla Arocha & Stephane Schraenen,
http://chicago.timeout.com/articles/art-design/90016/carla-arocha-and-stephane-schraenen-at-monique-meloche-art-story

- Paul Germanos